Top 10 Ways Twilight's and True Blood's Heroines Are Alike

Dead Until DarkVampires are hot these days. Two book series -- both with long runs on The New York Times Best Sellers List -- have made the leap from page to screen. Last month, HBO debuted True Blood, which is based on Charlaine Harris' eight-book The Southern Vampire Mysteries. And on November 21, Stephenie Meyer's Twilight saga hits theaters nationwide.

We asked Shelley Harper, a devoted fan of both series, active contributor to Twilightlexicon.com, and the woman behind Blue's Book Club, to share her insight about this vampire phenomenon and its heroines -- Bella Swan (Twilight) and Sookie Stackhouse (The Southern Vampire Mysteries and True Blood).

Here's what she had to say.

"Twilight's Bella is a popular high school girl eager to trade her soul for the love of her life -- the beautiful, noble, and self-despising Edward Cullen. Sookie is a telepathic Southern belle and waitress in a small town bar, who begrudges her special ability and captures the heart (and other parts) of many a hot supernatural creature, or "supe."

"The Twilight saga, while full of romantic teen angst, certainly does not have the dirty deeds behind a bar -- well, at least not that we see -- found in the Sookie Stackhouse tales. What could the stories of these two women possibly have in common besides estrogen and vampire romance? More than you think."

Twilight

Both Bella and Sookie Are

10. Inexperienced physically and emotionally as the story begins

9. Living with parent figures who guide many of their initial decisions

8. Thrust head first into an unreal world of supernatural creatures -- whether they wanted to know about them or not

7. Loved by supernaturally strong, hot vampire men who, strangely, have to be saved time and again by physically weaker women

6. Outcasts who, for the first time in their lives, develop close social ties and inhabit a place where they can be themselves

5. Quite edible smelling

4. Possessed of a strong character that makes them attractive to supernatural creatures (and to their fans)

3. The object of attention and desire of many a villainous character (see #5)

2. Self-sacrificing and protective of their loved ones

1. Bitten



Post this article to: Digg | del.icio.us | Facebook | MySpace | StumbleUpon | Fark | Reddit

User Comments

Please Log in or register to comment on Top 10 Ways Twilight's and True Blood's Heroines Are Alike.
  • cupressus

    11/17/08 02:59 PM
    Found a review:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXZi25kwhHA
    Review Rating: 0
    Characters remaining:
    Submit Cancel
  • cupressus

    11/17/08 01:31 PM
    You guys seem to be missing an article: Top 10 Ways Twilight and True Blood Are COMPLETELY DIFFERENT

    10. Angst cause by the supernatural in True Blood. Angst caused by teenage hormones in Twilight.

    9. True Blood is about vampires. Twilight is about teenagers (with some vampire hormones for additional angst).

    8. True Blood is an adult show with believable dialogue. Twilight is filled with campy humor and furrowed brows (see angst).

    7. True Blood has sex. Twilight talks about it, then feels some angst.

    6. True Blood chose chose actors based on experience and skill. Twilight chose its actors from the new Beverly Hills 90210 casting reject line: pretty kids that can't act.

    5. Bad things happen in True Blood. In Twilight, mildly annoying things happen.

    4. True Blood feels authentic due to: high production values (sets, props, lighting, sound), accents (actors doing well with variety of accents), on location filming in Louisiana. Twilight feels kinda' fake: typical bunch of spoiled teenagers living in a gated-community in sterile city in Southern California i.e what Hollywood sees as a typical teenager's family.

    3. True Blood has vampires, shape shifters, werewolves (apparently) and folks who are psychic (Sookie). Twilight has vampires and hormone-driven angst (listen to Bella's whining over cute vampire boy X).

    2. The comparison the 'True Blood' books and the 'Twilight' books is fine for a book forum: however, we are discussing video adaptation. No matter how the books compare, they will offer little insight as to the quality of each of the adaptations.

    1. Why are we discussing a movie that:
    A) has not been released into theaters yet
    B) HAS NOT BEEN REVIEWED!!!!! The movie opens in 4 days, but yet not one critic has received a copy for review? This usually indicates that the producers expect bad reviews from movie critics.

    Moderator: delete this post if you are accepting money / benefits for giving positive reviews of Twilight

    Review Rating: 0
    Characters remaining:
    Submit Cancel
  • damaen

    10/21/08 11:30 AM
    Hmm, I don't agree with #7. Bella doesn't save Edward at all really, not until the final book toward the end; not "time and again." Other than that, the rest is pretty interesting. I haven't read Sookie's story, but it's definitely on my to-read list.
    Review Rating: 0
    Characters remaining:
    Submit Cancel
  • SearchingForMyEdward

    10/16/08 10:18 PM
    im wondering...
    are the True Blood series good.
    by what i read of this they seem sorta like twilight...
    i wanna read it.
    please message me and tell me
    thanks.
    -tori.
    Review Rating: 0
    Characters remaining:
    Submit Cancel
    • Thoushallnotdie

      11/12/08 04:21 PM
      OMG!!!!! True Blood is great!!! I cant wait till every sunday rolls around so i can watch my show! I am also a fan of twilight and they are in many ways alike.
  • Therealthing

    10/16/08 09:37 AM
    So true and I think that the reason why vampires are so popular theses days is because the ending of harry potter fame!!! One the fame of harry potter had ended. Fans, like myself had lefted to find another series in which included magic and love. That is when everyone turned to The TWILIGHT SERIES and I am not sorry to say, but that series is here to stay, unlike the worthless harry potter series!!! That is 8 years of my life I would love to get back!!! No joke!!!
    Review Rating: 0
    Characters remaining:
    Submit Cancel
  • bardgirl

    10/14/08 11:08 PM
    Very true and to go with another vampire series vampires can be delicate flowers.
    Review Rating: 0
    Characters remaining:
    Submit Cancel
NEW MOVIE RELEASES
2009 |  2010 |  2011 |  2012
PAGES ON OUR
© 2009 ReelzChannel