In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Robert Pattinson plays Cedric Diggory, a 17-year-old Hogwarts student. In Twilight, he plays Edward Cullen, a perpetually 17-year-old student now enrolled at Forks High School. Both characters consistently prove their bravery, loyalty, and desire to do right.

Not much difference so far, right? But we got to thinking...Cedric is a wizard. Edward is a vampire. If the two squared off, who would win? See our judges' results below.

	Cedric Diggory	Edward Cullen
Visual appeal	"Cedric was a handsome young man, with chiseled features and grey eyes. Although he was as Seeker, a position usually taken by small and light players, he was well-built and burly." -- J.K. Rowling	"The last was lanky, less bulky, with untidy, bronze-colored hair.... [Like all the Cullens, he was] devastatingly, inhumanly beautiful." -- Stephenie Meyer (via Bella) WINNER
Hair-Touching Appeal	WINNER
School Success	Prefect and skilled wizard: "By your age he could turn a whistle into a watch and have it sing you the time." WINNER	Good at biology and all other subjects -- but who wouldn't be after graduating high school dozens of times?
Poster Success	Behind everyone except Viktor Krum	Front and center WINNER
Sporting Ability	Quidditch Seeker, Captain of Hufflepuff team, beat Harry Potter in his first match WINNER	Excels in Vampire Baseball by being the fastest of the Cullens
Scowling Ability	DRAW
School Popularity	Had the overwhelming support of Hogwarts students in Tri-Wizard Tournament WINNER	"People avoided him, as usual."
Virtual Popularity	Urban Dictionary entries -- 1 YouTube Channels -- 4 (video results = 1,200) Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer = 89%	Urban Dictionary entries -- 23 YouTube Channels -- 925 (video results = 29,900) Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer = 44% WINNER
Fighting Skills	Murdered by Peter Pettigrew (aka Wormtail), Death Eater who spent years disguised as a pet rat  DRAW	Killed rival vampire James, but only with help of his coven
	WINNER (by a wand's length)