MOVIE NEWS

Monday, December 8

  • Who Should Replace Hardwicke on New Moon?

    Twilight castTwilight lived up to some pretty lofty expectations, so the news that its director, Catherine Hardwicke, has flown the coop is rather disheartening. Hopefully, the film's success will mean that Summit can raise the bar even higher when it seeks out a helmer for the highly anticipated sequel. Of course, the sheer abundance of gun-for-hire hacks roaming the streets of Hollywood is enough to make any Twilight fan's skin stop sparkling.

    So who should direct Twilight's more-demanding, more-expensive sequel, New Moon? Alfonso Cuaron, who elevated the Harry Potter franchise from Chris Columbus' jumbled beginnings to the dark, superior third movie, Prisoner of Azkaban, would seem the perfect choice. He's got a consistently busy schedule, but he might be willing to rearrange if Summit makes an offer he can't refuse. Sofia Coppola could use a resurgence after the disappointing Marie Antoinette and has experience working with younger casts, though the auteur does tend to lean towards artier fare.

    Whatever happens, let's just cross our fingers that Paul W.S. Anderson and Brett Ratner are unavailable.

    Who would you like to see direct New Moon? Post a comment below and let us know!


    Posted 12/08/2008 by reelz

    Related: Sofia Coppola | Catherine Hardwicke | Marc Forster | Twilight | Bagong buwan (New Moon)

  • User Comments

    Please Log in or register to comment on Who Should Replace Hardwicke on New Moon?.
    • jessi

      01/20/09 02:36 PM
      I would choose directors like steven spielberg, Jerry Bruckheimer, or Micheal Bay. I am sure they will stick to the book. I thought Catherine Hardwicke was lame because she twisted the whole movie around. I love the books I read them thoroughly and she didn't get it exactly right and i got mad. After I watched the movie i read the book and i realized that she didn't put as much stuff from the book most of the stuff that she put did not happen like him coming out of the car to kill those guys supposidly never happened he opened the door for her.

      :D

      I didn't like catherine and i hope that the new director is better.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Krystina the Alien

      12/11/08 10:04 AM
      Well, as long as we don't get someone who will completely destroy the movie, then I'd be good.

      Alfonso Cuaron did an okay job with Prisoner of Azkaban, but I still was disappointed with the movie.

      All I care about is that the movie isn't destroyed. Keep up with Catharine's base, and we'll be good.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • berylspring

      12/10/08 10:23 AM
      I would prefer that Summit re-negotiate with Hardwick, as she has set the tone for the original film and as a fan of the series will work very hard to make it the best it could be.

      However, if I had to pick another director, I think Joss Whedon would be great! He is so very talented and can do both drama and comedy well.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Sherrie1

      12/10/08 09:33 AM
      Summit needs to find a director who understands the heart of the books, the relationship of Bella and Edward. It isn't all of the obsessive stuff, it's the story of two imperfect people who don't want to hurt each other but can't deny that they truly belong and help each other be stronger than they are without the other. Everything else that happens is the journey that gets them to that point.

      Summit, remember that we as fans went to the movie "Twilight" more than once (4 times in my case)not because we were enthralled with it, but because we were hopeful that by supporting it, the sequels will become what we hoped to see in the first movie.

      Improve the special effects, no more cat like crouches or road runnner like wire work. No more crazy camera angles. Get rid of the weird makeup.

      The new director needs to find a better balance with Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart in that I see their desire for the intensity of their roles but that he/she can reign them in and remind them that as an audience, we need to feel the joy as well as hopelessness. Remember, in the end, they have joy from finding each other even through all of the drama.

      The most important thing I hope for is that the new director does not buy into the idea that Edward needs to be shown during the time Bella has to survive without him in "New Moon". I think that the worst thing they could do is try to show us what is going on with him. As an audience, we need to have the same agonizing feelings of lost as Bella does during those months that drag past so that when we do get to see him again in Italy, we have the same elation and despair as she does.

      Summit, if you find a director who can do these things, I could care less if it is a female or male director, just the right one.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • what86

      12/09/08 06:44 PM
      I don’t think that what will effect the moves out come is more about a cheep the studio is, if they are willing to pay for a dissent director, because all on the list from Michael Bay to Stephen Sommers who would be totally awesome , just don’t think the studio can afford them to be franc, which is the reason why the choose Catherine in the first place. 30-40 million is what Tiwilight cost, and that lack of financing really shows in scenes and even poor editing. And New moon is a much more complex movie due to location like Italy and werewolves. So unless they increase the budget a decent movie won’t be made. Maybe they should get whoever directs Smallville, because a think that person knows how to work with limited tv budget and still make it look believable.

      But I think a perfect director would be Christopher Nolan who did the Dark Knight, I think he would get the dark conflicted mood of the book and the affects. Christopher Nolan would be perfect if the studio summet stopped being so cheap.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Millskelly1

      12/09/08 04:52 PM
      I can't believe Twilight fans aren't suggesting Stephenie Meyer for the director. She would make sure the movie would stay true to the book and pick the cast members without controversy and she'll do awesome! We'll have to have a really awesome special effects person/team to help her out. It would rock if she could direct the rest of the movies.
      I liked Catherine though. I'm sad, but there are other awesome directors out there.
      Review Rating: +1
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
      • donsher8

        12/10/08 08:32 AM
        I agree!! Stephenie would be awesome!! If they assigned an assistant director to help her, of course. she would be wonderful!! great idea.
    • miharuskii

      12/09/08 03:03 PM
      nohophoenix- I like your thinking! I love his directing. And he has a wide range of generes he has done and is looking at doing.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • MrsJasperWhitlockHale

      12/09/08 02:43 PM
      I Think Michael Bay :)
      He directs transformers and is great with Special effects and thats what new moon need with the wolves and such.
      And Hardwicke was ok but the stunts and effects in twilight were Cheezy and looked waaaay fake.
      I think Michael Bay would be perfect
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Air

      12/09/08 02:06 PM
      I think that Richard Kelly should direct New Moon
      He directed Donnie Darko and he has an understanding of what dark should be!
      New Moon is not a 'happy' film...
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • mysduende

      12/09/08 01:57 PM
      Catherine Hardwicke back - or - a female director that Catherine entrusts.
      Review Rating: -1
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • ecskfevr

      12/09/08 01:45 PM
      Sam Raimi.... he'd be good with special effects and stuff in New Moon
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • nohophoenix

      12/09/08 12:50 PM
      I have to vote for my top wish list director for the project and that would be Joss Whedon. Yeah, sure vampire stuff and all. BUT, much more to the point, he knows how to bring the pain and anguish that Bella feels in the book to the screen. He can emotionally devastate characters in such beautiful,eloquent ways. No one I feel has a more completely spot on resume than Joss. Also, as a writer, he can also pull from the book and adapt the flow of the movie much better than Twilight hacked up the pacing of that adaptation. He knows SFX and action sequences and knows all about a budget. So hands down, I vote for Joss!
      Review Rating: +1
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Punkbrunettegirl

      12/09/08 11:59 AM
      Catherine Hardwicke did an amazing job on Twilight. She is an amazing director. I love all her movies. I want HER back. But because Catherine Hardwicke isn't coming back I choose Sofia Coppola.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • la_tua_cantante

      12/09/08 11:57 AM
      MYOPINION...yo so rock! I thought I was the only one who thought of Guillermo del Toro....glad to c i'm not!
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • la_tua_cantante

      12/09/08 11:54 AM
      Donsher8...that's rediculous to say that you wouldn't see New Moon if Alfonso Cuaron directed it. Personally I really like Hp- Azkaban....Anyway to say u wouldn't watch NM because of that is just sad! If u call yourself a fan then u should give the movie a chance no matter what! Then make your decision.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
      • o0msj0o

        12/09/08 07:04 PM
        I'm glad to see that someone can truly appreciate the works of Guillermo del Toro and Alfonso Cuaron. My fave HP was Azkaban. And he was amazing at Children of Men. I don't think many people appreciate or understand his style of directing. I'm a huge fan of all his work. But I'm 100% with u on Guillermo del Toro. He's sooo good at creating fantasy pieces. And he's amazing at bringing out true human emotion. I think he can capture Bella's loneliness and desperation better than any other director. I just hope they have a bigger budget to make the SFX look less ****ty. I'm glad Hardwicke's off the next project. Don't get me wrong...she's a good director. I've seen all her movies. She's just not right for this one.
    • la_tua_cantante

      12/09/08 11:50 AM
      I think Guillermo Del Toro would be a good director!...Anyone see Pan's Labyrinth
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • hollywoodsurfer4

      12/09/08 11:48 AM
      I think Director Joe Wright would be great for New Moon, and possibly the rest of the series. He is still pretty indie but gain quite a bit of clout with such movies as Pride and Prejudice and Atonement. Also, his newest movie, the Soloist, is going to be released sometime next year and it looks super good. I think he would be the perfect director to translate the romance and action from the pages of the books on to the screen.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • myopinion

      12/09/08 11:41 AM
      Guillermo del Toro would do a good job - but I suspect he is way too busy with Hobbits right now.

      Hellboy and Twilight had a number of common elements - the supernatural trying to blend into our world, a love story/love triangle/breakup, a charming (in his own way) male lead character heroically battling against his demonic nature, a noble, guiding father figure, an unplanned pregnancy, male lead who would do ANYTHING to save his female love, evil supernatural beings to battle, philosophical messages on the meaning of humanity and the soul, bitter enemies becoming friends - among other items.

      New Moon is a darker story than Twilight - Guillermo del Toro would be able to give it an appropriate feel. Rolling Stone had some interesting words from Mr. Pattinson on this other side of Edward that would be interesting to explore in future movies.

      http://www.rollingstone.com/news/story/24945469/hot_actor_qa_with_twilight_s

      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Angel27

      12/09/08 10:28 AM
      NewMillenium- I agree with you about keeping Edward out until he reappears in Italy, but I read an article today (LA Times maybe?) that Melissa R. did find a way to weave him in... :s
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Angel27

      12/09/08 10:26 AM
      Okay- forget what I said before. After reading MTV's director list (it comes with a list of films they've done- which was very helpful), I have a better idea- David Fincher!

      Why?

      He’s captured the following on film before from AMAZING actors (and we have those in our leads)–>

      ROMANCE (ex: Benjamin Button)
      ACTION (ex: Fight club)
      DRAMA (ex: all of the above)

      Plus, having worked with Brad Pitt, Kate Blanchet and Ed Norton- I trust that he can pull even better performances out of Stewart and Pattinson. They are budding actors after all. There’s only room to grow! :P
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • NewMillenium

      12/09/08 09:47 AM
      I think Jon Turtletaub would do an excellent job with all of the action, subtle humor, and mild-but-not-pushy romance in New Moon, IF he read the books and could get into the series.

      Stephen Sommers or any director of a movie similar to Twilight would blow it out of proportion, because they would use the styles THEY have already used and ignore the fact that New Moon has it's own flair to discover.

      Twilight just needs a director that isn't pressured to change the book too much. Like the completely idiotic idea of adding Edward(awesome as he may be)in more of New Moon. It's a bad idea. Sorry, but it is. The longer you keep screaming girls waiting, the more excited they get, and the movie will succesfully draw out tension the way it's supposed to.
      Review Rating: +1
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • NewMillenium

      12/09/08 09:47 AM
      I think Jon Turtletaub would do an excellent job with all of the action, subtle humor, and mild-but-not-pushy romance in New Moon, IF he read the books and could get into the series.

      Stephen Sommers or any director of a movie similar to Twilight would blow it out of proportion, because they would use the styles THEY have already used and ignore the fact that New Moon has it's own flair to discover.

      Twilight just needs a director that isn't pressured to change the book too much. Like the completely idiotic idea of adding Edward(awesome as he may be)in more of New Moon. It's a bad idea. Sorry, but it is. The longer you keep screaming girls waiting, the more excited they get, and the movie will succesfully draw out tension the way it's supposed to.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • NewMillenium

      12/09/08 09:47 AM
      I think Jon Turtletaub would do an excellent job with all of the action, subtle humor, and mild-but-not-pushy romance in New Moon, IF he read the books and could get into the series.

      Stephen Sommers or any director of a movie similar to Twilight would blow it out of proportion, because they would use the styles THEY have already used and ignore the fact that New Moon has it's own flair to discover.

      Twilight just needs a director that isn't pressured to change the book too much. Like the completely idiotic idea of adding Edward(awesome as he may be)in more of New Moon. It's a bad idea. Sorry, but it is. The longer you keep screaming girls waiting, the more excited they get, and the movie will succesfully draw out tension the way it's supposed too.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • willshell

      12/09/08 09:11 AM
      I would love to see Ron Howard direct the "New Moon" film
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • donsher8

      12/09/08 09:00 AM
      Alfonso Cuaron is NOT a good choice. If you look over the 5 harry potter movies, Azkaban was the poorest selling movie of all, in theaters and on DVD. If he does do New Moon, this is one fan who will not see it! He would be a Major mistake!
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • my3honeybeez

      12/09/08 08:59 AM
      Stephen Sommers whom directed Van Helsing, would be my first choice. His werewolves were absolutely perfect and a near match to Stephenie Meyers descriptions. Alfonso Cuaron would be my second choice, because lets face it, the Harry Potter films are awesome. He has done an outstanding job!
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    • Angel27

      12/08/08 10:45 PM
      I would be very interested to see what Sofia Coppola could do with the films... I don't know if the action elements in the series (and I think there is a substantial amount) are necessarily up her alley, but I trust she would capture the tone and performances needed to keep these movies from being your typical teenie bopper movie. KIMBERLY PIERCE, from Boys Don't Cry would be great too. :)

      So long as whomever they get does not think that because they're adapting a young-adult novel that it needs to be "cooky" in any way.
      Review Rating: 0
      Characters remaining:
      Submit Cancel
    See the most recent outtakes

Movie News

Movie News is our take on the world of movies. Every day our crack staff reports on what's happening, what's worth watching, and what should've never been made in the first place.

Got a scoop?  Email us at news@reelzchannel.com.

reelz video highlight

Surrogates Trailer
Opens September 25, 2009

 
NEW MOVIE RELEASES
2009 |  2010 |  2011 |  2012
PAGES ON OUR
© 2009 ReelzChannel